Rehnquist: $15 Circuit City Gift Card.
Thomas: Previously-viewed Boat Trip DVD.
Kennedy: Regifted six-slice toaster she gave him for his birthday.
Ginsburg: Was going to give the new Kanye West album until she listened to "Golddigga," at which point she decided to keep it for herself and just give a humongous bag of blow.
Stevens: His lucky bow tie.
Breyer: Dice clock.
Scalia: Surprised her by showing up to her chambers with a guitar and performing a soulful rendition of John Mayer's "Your Body is a Wonderland."
Souter: RoboSapien. Sweet.